COMMERCIAL INSURANCE CONDITIONS
Pockets of space for buyers
Despite economic and geopolitical uncertainty, the insurance industry remains financially strong.
P&C insurers’ underwriting gains in the first quarter of 2026 totaled $22.1 billion, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence, and its combined ratio before policyholder dividends was 89.1%. S&P described Q1 as the industry’s “strongest first quarter in 25 years.” Leading carriers reported strong performance, backed by disciplined underwriting and favorable investment conditions.
IN UNDERWRITING GAINS, THE industry’s “strongest first quarter in 25 years.”
Data from AM Best also highlights the industry’s strong financial positioning. In 2025:
INSURERS’ INVESTMENT INCOME
increased by 13%, the second consecutive year of double-digit growth.
MEDIAN RETURN ON CAPITAL EMPLOYED (ROCE)5
was 12.41%, the third consecutive year that ROCE exceeded cost of capital.
RETURN ON EQUITY
increased to 14.97%, the highest in more than a decade.
After years of inadequate pricing and rising loss costs, the industry has restored discipline. Capital is available, competition is growing, and buyers are seeing more stable pricing and broader market access. The tailwinds driving recent performance, however, may not persist.
Midway through 2026, insurers face three key questions:
01
How long will investment returns continue to climb?
Investment portfolios performed well in 2025, and equity markets have continued rising in 2026 despite geopolitical and inflation concerns. Higher rates support fixed income, but continued double-digit growth is unlikely, and rate cuts would pressure returns.
02
Were lower catastrophe losses in 2025 an outlier?
A quiet Atlantic hurricane season contributed to fewer catastrophe losses in 2025, but risk remains cyclical and event-driven. An active 2026 hurricane season could reshape the market. Even in a relatively benign 2025, insurers absorbed more than $100 billion in natural catastrophe losses, according to the Swiss Re Institute, leaving little margin for error.
03
How will insurers react to stagnant or declining exposure bases?
Exposure growth is slowing across many sectors, removing a key source of top-line growth. Carriers must explore new growth strategies, from specialty expansion and new products to geographic diversification and M&A. But that growth will remain disciplined, particularly in lines where loss costs and severity trends remain elevated. For buyers, this should create more competition in stable, well-performing segments, but not across the board. Risks exposed to inflation, litigation, catastrophic losses, credit stress, or operational volatility will continue to face more scrutiny and fewer options.
Structural market shifts & capital dynamics
Several trends point to a market that is growing in both efficiency and complexity.
Capital fragmentation & alternative structures
Capital is increasingly fragmented and targeted, with insurers and investors seeking alignment with specific risk appetites. This has led to more alternative structures, including facilities, fronting arrangements,6 and delegated authority7 models.
The shift is away from traditional balance sheet underwriting toward a more distributed, data-driven capital model. That offers buyers more options but requires scrutiny: Who is assuming risk? Who controls underwriting decisions? How durable is that capacity?8
Facilities & portfolio solutions
Brokers are increasingly aggregating portfolios and placing them with one or more carriers through structured facilities. This can enable faster placements and more consistent coverage across portfolios. Advances in data and analytics, digital platforms, and AI-driven insights have accelerated this transition.
Facilities, however, can present downsides, including reduced competition. When auto-follow behavior dominates and carriers accept lead terms without underwriting scrutiny, complacency can set in on both sides. This can limit optimization of pricing, structure, and coverage and leave buyers with less competitive outcomes than they might otherwise achieve.
MGA/MGU growth
Managing general agents (MGAs) and managing general underwriters (MGUs)9 account for an estimated $110 billion in premiums, representing a significant share of the U.S. commercial insurance market. Growth has been driven by private equity investment and the rise of broker-owned underwriting platforms.
MGAs offer buyers specialization, speed, and niche expertise, but the model carries some risks. Much of the capacity offered by MGAs is untested. MGAs can enter markets aggressively, exit quickly when losses emerge, and leave buyers exposed with little warning. Claims handling authority, advocacy, and continuity under MGAs can also be unclear.
M&A activity
Strong insurer profitability has brought capital allocation under scrutiny. With high returns on equity, many are looking to expand through increased specialization or new geographies.
M&A activity is likely to continue, although dealmaking remains sensitive to interest rates and inflation. Carriers enter the current environment well capitalized, with ROE at its highest level in over a decade. But how that capital gets deployed will vary significantly by organization, with management teams weighing organic growth, M&A, buybacks, and simply holding on to cash.
Reinsurance & capital discipline
Reinsurance remains an important driver of market behavior. Capacity is generally available, but reinsurers and capital providers remain focused on attachment points,10 terms, volatility, and returns. That discipline is influencing how primary insurers deploy capital, where they are willing to grow, and which structures they support.
Capital is not scarce, but carriers are deploying it more precisely, toward risk profiles, structures, and portfolios where returns are clear and volatility is understood.
Issues to watch
Several challenges could accelerate into more significant threats for both insurers and insureds.
Social inflation
Rising claim severity, nuclear verdicts, and escalating defense costs continue to pressure casualty lines.
More than creating new losses, social inflation is exposing weaknesses in prior underwriting, including inadequate pricing, broad terms, and risk selection that underestimated long-tail volatility. These issues surface over time as claims develop, increasing pressure on reserves.
Early signs of reserve strengthening suggest loss trends may be worse than previously recognized. As carriers reassess prior years, the impact could extend to capacity, pricing, and underwriting appetite across casualty markets.
GEOPOLITICS
Geopolitical tensions remain a material source of risk for insurance buyers, even with a preliminary agreement between the United States and Iran reducing near-term volatility.
Ongoing conflicts — including Russia-Ukraine and strained U.S.-China relations — continue to disrupt energy markets, trade flows, and supply chains, with direct implications for property, business interruption, marine, cyber, and political risk exposures.
Buyers with international operations should reassess whether coverage and limits adequately reflect evolving geopolitical and supply chain risks.
BOND MARKET
JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon has warned that rising government debt, elevated energy prices, and persistent geopolitical stress could trigger a sudden and disorderly jump in bond yields. In 2023, unrealized losses on bond portfolios contributed to the failures of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank.
Like banks, insurers depend heavily on fixed income returns. A sudden bond market shift would compress investment income and force carriers to reassess underwriting appetite and capacity.
For buyers, carriers could pull back from certain lines, reduce limits, or reprice risks with little warning — especially for complex casualty programs reliant on few carriers.
Turning chances into goals
With competition increasing and capacity widely available, buyers have more room to maneuver than they have had in years.
Today’s market gives many buyers better field position, but potential shifts in economic, geopolitical, and loss trends make it critical to strengthen programs now, while conditions remain favorable.
The best-positioned companies will be those that look beyond routine renewals and take deliberate action. These companies will:
+
Optimize structures, retentions, and limits.
+
Stress-test programs through scenario analyses to understand potential weaknesses and gaps.
+
Secure multiyear arrangements where viable.
+
Actively manage selection of insurers and other sources of risk capital.
5Return on capital employed (ROCE): Measures how efficiently a company generates operating profits from the capital it uses. ROCE is expressed as a ratio and is typically calculated by dividing operating income by capital employed. (See glossary.)
6Fronting arrangements: An arrangement in which a licensed insurer issues a policy on behalf of a captive, reinsurer, or self-insured program, often retaining little or no ultimate risk. Captives, which are insurance companies owned and controlled by insured for their own risks, may use a fronting carrier to satisfy licensing, admitted paper, regulatory, or contractual requirements. (See glossary.)
7Delegated authority: Authority granted by an insurer to a third party to perform specified insurance functions, such as underwriting, binding coverage, issuing policies, collecting premiums, or handling claims, subject to defined limits and oversight. (See glossary.)
8Capacity: In property and casualty insurance, capacity refers to the maximum amount of risk an insurer, reinsurer, or the overall market is willing or able to underwrite. Capacity is determined by capital levels, risk appetite, pricing adequacy, and regulatory constraints. It can apply to policy limits, total exposure, or the number of policies written within an individual line or geographic location. (See glossary.)
9Managing general underwriter (MGU: An insurance intermediary granted authority by an insurer to perform specific functions, such as risk selection, underwriting, and binding. MGUs typically do not handle claims or broader administrative functions. (See glossary.)
10Attachment point: The point at which excess coverage or reinsurance will begin to respond. Once losses exceed the attachment point, excess insurance or reinsurance policies pay claims up to their stated limits. (See glossary.)
© 2026 Lockton Companies. All rights reserved.